JULIAN MACIAS
Here’s a revised selection of the best pizza slices in New York City, focusing exclusively on pizzerias that sell slices and are highly regarded by locals and visitors alike. In case you don’t know how to order a slice of pizza in New York City we made a guide for you.
Top Pizza Slices in NYC
Joe’s Pizza
– Location: Multiple locations, including Greenwich Village
– A quintessential New York slice, Joe’s Pizza is famous for its classic cheese slices with a perfect balance of sauce and cheese. The crispy yet foldable crust makes it a favorite among locals and tourists alike.
L&B Spumoni Gardens
– Location: Brooklyn
– Known for its thick, square Sicilian slices, L&B Spumoni Gardens features a crispy crust topped with rich tomato sauce and gooey cheese. Their unique style has made it a must-visit for pizza lovers.
Mama’s TOO!
– Location: Upper West Side
– This pizzeria is celebrated for its deliciously crafted slices, including a standout grandma slice with a crispy base and flavorful toppings. Mama’s TOO! offers a modern twist on classic New York-style pizza.
Prince Street Pizza
– Location: Nolita
– Famous for its spicy pepperoni cups that create pools of flavorful grease on their Sicilian slices, Prince Street Pizza is a go-to for those seeking a distinctive pizza experience. Their pies are consistently praised for flavor and quality.
Scarr’s Pizza
– Location: Lower East Side
– Scarr’s is known for its commitment to high-quality ingredients and traditional methods. The classic cheese slice is particularly popular, offering a no-frills yet satisfying experience that embodies the essence of New York pizza.
Pizza Wagon
– Location: Bay Ridge
– Dating back to 1966, Pizza Wagon is celebrated for its cozy atmosphere and delicious Sicilian slices with a light, crisp crust and generous layers of cheese. It remains a beloved neighborhood staple.
Halsey Street
– Location: Bedford-Stuyvesant
– This pizzeria features slightly thicker crusts and inventive toppings. The margarita slice topped with fresh mozzarella and herbs is particularly memorable, making it a great spot for unique flavors.
NY Pizza Suprema
– Location: Near Madison Square Garden
– Renowned for its classic New York slices, NY Pizza Suprema offers a variety of toppings while maintaining the traditional taste that locals love. The cheese slice here is a must-try.
Corner Slice
– Location: Gotham West Market
– Known for elevating the New York slice experience, Corner Slice offers unique square pies crafted with artisan flours and various cheese blends, making it stand out among traditional pizzerias.
Pizzatown
– Location: Park Slope
– A vibrant pizzeria known for its eclectic offerings, Pizzatown features thicker crusts along with unique options like Buffalo chicken and vodka slices, appealing to those looking for something different.
New York City’s pizza scene is diverse and vibrant, offering an array of options from classic styles to innovative toppings. These pizzerias not only serve some of the best slices in the city but also reflect the rich culinary culture that makes NYC a pizza lover’s paradise. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or savoring each slice, these spots are essential stops for any pizza enthusiast visiting the city.
Image credit Clay Williams